I am no fan of authority. I've worked against it, with it, in it and as it. The need to challenge it constantly I found surprisingly common and supremely necessary in every iteration. So, I do not lightly say that without coherent, forceful and responsible leadership, the OWS movement is going nowhere but down, probably at its own hands.
The recent flag burning in Oakland was the work of fools or worse. I am not going to waste my time or the reader's time arguing the point. How's that for an authoritative statement? Well, my little dears of the OWS, you should not only get used to it, you should crave it. It is the only hope you have. Indeed, it is the only hope we have of building a real movement of value and accomplishment.
Think of Dr. King in the 60s, and his commitment to non-violence. If the Civil Rights movement had not had his strong and unyielding leadership on that commitment, the more radical and/or intentional provocateurs would have killed the cause in its crib. Nothing would have been accomplished. So, whether the stupidity comes from within or the attack comes in the form of mischief cooked up by plants from the outside, a progressive movement needs leadership to overcome it, stick to an effective course of action, win support, and outlast the opposition.
Tuesday, January 31, 2012
Friday, January 27, 2012
To The Moon, Alice!
Only those of a certain age or mavens of old-timey t.v. show reruns will recognize that comic-hollow threat, oft issued by Ralph Cramden to his wife, Alice, in The Honeymooners. Whether for entirely appropriate and sound reasons or just overdone political correctness, things have changed dramatically. Even two truly great thespians, like Jackie Gleason and Audrey Meadows, could no longer squeeze a smile out of that classic scene, wherein an overgrown galoot offers his physically petite wife a free lunar cruise courtesy of a right cross, as she icily, confidently, and silently responds with a killer "stuff it, buster" stare. Although other things have changed as well, some things never do. Mitt Romney reminded us of that last night.
One change is that Romney has gotten much better at debating Gingrich. We're told he hired a new debate coach to help him in this regard. I suppose Mitt won't get the pleasure of firing this new service provider, as the results seem to have showed up rather well last night. A particular instance was the exchange in which Mitt effectively ridiculed Newt's lunar lunacy. But one wonders what it says about Mitt that a debate coach was required to arm him for such an easy take down. Still, there is even more to be said about what was revealed in this colloquy. And it may make Mitt want to rethink the debate coach service after all.
Newt's whole pie in the sky moon shot is based on getting private business to take on the project. Mitt responded that he would fire any business associate who approached him with such an idea. He thereby admitted that the private sector wants one thing and one thing only: immediate profit, and lots of it, for the least amount of effort. Time and time again, it has been proven that we are going nowhere as a nation and a people by following that philosophy in our governance. Last night, Romney and Gingrich both stipulated as much, but they are too stupid to realize it. Only "We the people" can do the heavy lifting of moving civilization forward. That is the job of government. Business is something else again.
One change is that Romney has gotten much better at debating Gingrich. We're told he hired a new debate coach to help him in this regard. I suppose Mitt won't get the pleasure of firing this new service provider, as the results seem to have showed up rather well last night. A particular instance was the exchange in which Mitt effectively ridiculed Newt's lunar lunacy. But one wonders what it says about Mitt that a debate coach was required to arm him for such an easy take down. Still, there is even more to be said about what was revealed in this colloquy. And it may make Mitt want to rethink the debate coach service after all.
Newt's whole pie in the sky moon shot is based on getting private business to take on the project. Mitt responded that he would fire any business associate who approached him with such an idea. He thereby admitted that the private sector wants one thing and one thing only: immediate profit, and lots of it, for the least amount of effort. Time and time again, it has been proven that we are going nowhere as a nation and a people by following that philosophy in our governance. Last night, Romney and Gingrich both stipulated as much, but they are too stupid to realize it. Only "We the people" can do the heavy lifting of moving civilization forward. That is the job of government. Business is something else again.
Wednesday, January 25, 2012
The Shock Of Recognition
Manufacturing????? What's that?
Yes, zerO's main theme last night came with every ornament and adornment except a loudly unspoken and much needed admission by the phony leaders of the equally phony Liberal establishment that has grown up in the last 40 years in this country. Ahem, that is that the only genuine Liberalism is economic Liberalism. Everything else is mere capitulation to the most rapacious rip-off class of plutocrats the world has ever known. And that a broad middle class simply cannot be sustained in the absence of continued commitment to the creation of real wealth, through real work, not bullshit financial abuse.
You could hear it and see it in his tone and manner. ZerO finally gets it. We have damn near thrown it all away, and it scares the hell out of him. It should scare you, too.
Yes, zerO's main theme last night came with every ornament and adornment except a loudly unspoken and much needed admission by the phony leaders of the equally phony Liberal establishment that has grown up in the last 40 years in this country. Ahem, that is that the only genuine Liberalism is economic Liberalism. Everything else is mere capitulation to the most rapacious rip-off class of plutocrats the world has ever known. And that a broad middle class simply cannot be sustained in the absence of continued commitment to the creation of real wealth, through real work, not bullshit financial abuse.
You could hear it and see it in his tone and manner. ZerO finally gets it. We have damn near thrown it all away, and it scares the hell out of him. It should scare you, too.
Tuesday, January 24, 2012
The Downpression
Long before anyone outside of Arkansas had ever heard of Bill Clinton, the world was going to hell for American workers. Clinton didn't draw up the road map to our economic dead end, but he did lock in the GPS coordinates, and stomp on the gas. He screwed us permanently by passing the Permanent Normal Trade Relations with China (PNTR) and the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) treaties. He did those things mostly in obedience to the demands of the multi-national corporations, which pretty much own and operate this country and the world. And he also did it out of a misguided notion that exporting traditional American manufacturing jobs would provide a better way of life for the most downtrodden and exploited workers on the planet, while causing industry and workers here at home to graduate to a higher or more sophisticated level of production. The theory being that everyone here would leave the dirty, sweaty, hard work of yesterday's economy behind, and virtually keystroke our way to economic nirvana. It was the tragically misguided modern Liberal idea of a Brave New World economy.
Decades earlier, though, the dumping of high-end, labor intensive manufactured products and commodities on the American market by foreign countries and companies had already begun the process of destroying middle class jobs and living standards. Dumping is the illegal trade practice of selling manufactured products below cost into foreign markets in times of excess productive capacity at home. It is done to keep homeland factories and workers going, and to win market share.
By the early 1970s this predatory practice was well on the way to hobbling the U.S. steel, auto, electronics, and industrial machinery industries. As a result, workers and unions came under immense economic and political pressure. Workers and unions faced job losses, pay cuts, and false blame for the overall social suffering. Cut-throat competition arose among American workers, and unions started to crater from internal as well as external pressure. This really marked the beginning of the end of the American middle class.
At first, some U.S. industries, notably steel and auto, tried to pursue legal redress of the illegal foreign invasion. While there were many instances wherein their claims were validated, the remedies were woefully insufficient, a joke actually. Soon enough, corporations engaged in the production of high-end consumer goods in America began to abandon their own work force for cheaper production capacity abroad. They found it in the form of damn near free or slave labor all around the globe.
This was true even before the collapse of the Soviet Union and the transition of China from a communist to a capitalist totalitarian state. Those two events disgorged an almost inexhaustible supply of free workers, at least by our standards, onto the world market. And the response of the modern false Liberals, like Clinton, was to capitulate entirely to the powerful money interests.
They invented a jingoistic and pornographically seductive siren call to the younger American generation. There were essentially two key parts to it. The scruffy, bedraggled, Dickensian rabble of the third world would take on the burden of the dirty, smutty, smoke-stack industries, and thereby dramatically improve their own meager economic circumstances. Most Americans would transition into the high tech information based economy, and do better than ever before. They would do the hard physical work, we would handle the smart, intellectual services, and everyone would live happily ever after. A significant majority of young Americans bought this ugly, privilege-drenched pitch.
Unfortunately, an awful lot of unhappiness has resulted from this echo of empire delusion on the way to the ever after. Not the least of which has been the near destruction of the middle class here as well as in much of the developed world, and the indefinite bondage to landless, forced labor destitution for the majority of the earth's population.
The workers of the privileged world willingly overlooked the perpetual plight of downtrodden, oppressed third world workers, subject to unspeakably dehumanizing working conditions for absurdly low compensation, while kidding themselves that they could enjoy a prosperous future without the need to generate real wealth.
Today, we find ourselves heading up again slightly in terms of the so-called "business cycle." Many no doubt will giddily embrace the relief from the painful "G" force pressure of steep decline. They will delude themselves for a while into believing that the vigor of former times will somehow naturally be restored to their living standards. They will be disappointed.
Again we are going to top out at a lower level of vitality than we enjoyed before the decline set in. The good jobs lost in the crash will not be fully restored. For full recovery to happen, we need a total cleaning out and overhaul of the political and economic system. That may be in the works, go OWS. But for now I would nominate a new word for our lexicon. In Jamaica they call this perpetual pattern of pain and suffering downpression. I think it fits.
Decades earlier, though, the dumping of high-end, labor intensive manufactured products and commodities on the American market by foreign countries and companies had already begun the process of destroying middle class jobs and living standards. Dumping is the illegal trade practice of selling manufactured products below cost into foreign markets in times of excess productive capacity at home. It is done to keep homeland factories and workers going, and to win market share.
By the early 1970s this predatory practice was well on the way to hobbling the U.S. steel, auto, electronics, and industrial machinery industries. As a result, workers and unions came under immense economic and political pressure. Workers and unions faced job losses, pay cuts, and false blame for the overall social suffering. Cut-throat competition arose among American workers, and unions started to crater from internal as well as external pressure. This really marked the beginning of the end of the American middle class.
At first, some U.S. industries, notably steel and auto, tried to pursue legal redress of the illegal foreign invasion. While there were many instances wherein their claims were validated, the remedies were woefully insufficient, a joke actually. Soon enough, corporations engaged in the production of high-end consumer goods in America began to abandon their own work force for cheaper production capacity abroad. They found it in the form of damn near free or slave labor all around the globe.
This was true even before the collapse of the Soviet Union and the transition of China from a communist to a capitalist totalitarian state. Those two events disgorged an almost inexhaustible supply of free workers, at least by our standards, onto the world market. And the response of the modern false Liberals, like Clinton, was to capitulate entirely to the powerful money interests.
They invented a jingoistic and pornographically seductive siren call to the younger American generation. There were essentially two key parts to it. The scruffy, bedraggled, Dickensian rabble of the third world would take on the burden of the dirty, smutty, smoke-stack industries, and thereby dramatically improve their own meager economic circumstances. Most Americans would transition into the high tech information based economy, and do better than ever before. They would do the hard physical work, we would handle the smart, intellectual services, and everyone would live happily ever after. A significant majority of young Americans bought this ugly, privilege-drenched pitch.
Unfortunately, an awful lot of unhappiness has resulted from this echo of empire delusion on the way to the ever after. Not the least of which has been the near destruction of the middle class here as well as in much of the developed world, and the indefinite bondage to landless, forced labor destitution for the majority of the earth's population.
The workers of the privileged world willingly overlooked the perpetual plight of downtrodden, oppressed third world workers, subject to unspeakably dehumanizing working conditions for absurdly low compensation, while kidding themselves that they could enjoy a prosperous future without the need to generate real wealth.
Today, we find ourselves heading up again slightly in terms of the so-called "business cycle." Many no doubt will giddily embrace the relief from the painful "G" force pressure of steep decline. They will delude themselves for a while into believing that the vigor of former times will somehow naturally be restored to their living standards. They will be disappointed.
Again we are going to top out at a lower level of vitality than we enjoyed before the decline set in. The good jobs lost in the crash will not be fully restored. For full recovery to happen, we need a total cleaning out and overhaul of the political and economic system. That may be in the works, go OWS. But for now I would nominate a new word for our lexicon. In Jamaica they call this perpetual pattern of pain and suffering downpression. I think it fits.
Thursday, January 19, 2012
The Will To Believe, Or ... False Liberals Take The Easy Way Out
The phrase "natural experiment" is a term of art used in the field of economics. It basically means holding up a hypothetical economic model to real world experience as a means of validating or invalidating a particular model's predictions. Even a casual look at such a practice suggests the inherent weakness of potentially drawing undue conclusions from rather anecdotal evidence. Nonetheless, the power and utility of some "natural experiments" can be very strong and reliable. A good rule of thumb is to impute greater soundness to the larger and more generalized natural or real world experiences.
So, now that we have accumulated literally decades of experience under a system of open and unregulated trade with every hell hole labor abuser and environmental despoiler on the planet, what can we say has been produced? A pernicious and persistent decline of working and living standards for the vast majority of the American population. Repeated cycles of recession, followed by a truly oxymoronicly termed "jobless" recovery, which has excavated an unemployment canyon, the walls of which most of us have no hope of ever scaling.
Generations have already been laid low, and more are heading down. Much of this, mind you, was the handiwork of false liberals like Bill Clinton and others who found it easier to capitulate to the powerful interests, than to actually insist on seeking development of the third world through a more moral and humane way, while safeguarding our own hard-won standards here at home.
More on the failure of these false liberals and our collective tragedy in the next post.
So, now that we have accumulated literally decades of experience under a system of open and unregulated trade with every hell hole labor abuser and environmental despoiler on the planet, what can we say has been produced? A pernicious and persistent decline of working and living standards for the vast majority of the American population. Repeated cycles of recession, followed by a truly oxymoronicly termed "jobless" recovery, which has excavated an unemployment canyon, the walls of which most of us have no hope of ever scaling.
Generations have already been laid low, and more are heading down. Much of this, mind you, was the handiwork of false liberals like Bill Clinton and others who found it easier to capitulate to the powerful interests, than to actually insist on seeking development of the third world through a more moral and humane way, while safeguarding our own hard-won standards here at home.
More on the failure of these false liberals and our collective tragedy in the next post.
Wednesday, January 18, 2012
Show Me A Picture Of The Money
In the previous post, we borrowed a graph from Paul Krugman's work which he used to demonstrate the continuing effectiveness of fiscal stimulus, even in the age of globalization. We also commented that common sense alone would lead to the same conclusion, and that those who made different claims were either out to lunch or had simply given up on the idea of actively using proven policy measures to resurrect a moribund economy.
Today, we present another useful graphic depiction of an aspect of the current economic times, and would add that anyone who has been around long enough to have worked and earned a living over the last thirty-odd years has come to understand this lamentable development on the strength of bitter experience alone. Further, we would append a note indicating that the combination of the two Krugman graphs, and the accompanying explanations, produces an ineluctable conclusion to which we should pay heed.
Had we not embarked on the blind venture into totally open and unsupervised trade with slave labor, non-democratic nation states over the last three or four decades, we would today be spending much closer to 100% of our dollars on American produced goods, inclusive of the higher end, labor intensive, value added commodities. This not only strongly implies a much higher GDP over that same period, but also that workers would have been employed in much better paying jobs.
And the widening inequality of income and shredding of the middle-class would not have happened.
Here is the Krugman post:
Today, we present another useful graphic depiction of an aspect of the current economic times, and would add that anyone who has been around long enough to have worked and earned a living over the last thirty-odd years has come to understand this lamentable development on the strength of bitter experience alone. Further, we would append a note indicating that the combination of the two Krugman graphs, and the accompanying explanations, produces an ineluctable conclusion to which we should pay heed.
Had we not embarked on the blind venture into totally open and unsupervised trade with slave labor, non-democratic nation states over the last three or four decades, we would today be spending much closer to 100% of our dollars on American produced goods, inclusive of the higher end, labor intensive, value added commodities. This not only strongly implies a much higher GDP over that same period, but also that workers would have been employed in much better paying jobs.
And the widening inequality of income and shredding of the middle-class would not have happened.
Here is the Krugman post:
Things We’re Supposed To Be Quiet About
Apologists for rising inequality often argue that since most Americans’ income has risen despite rising inequality, there’s no reason to complain about inequality other than envy. So it’s worth remembering that we used to expect economic growth to deliver large increases in real income, not just a bit of a rise that’s accomplished in large part through longer working hours; and that a major reason so many have seen such small gains is that a large part of growth has been siphoned off to the very high end.
Lane Kenworthy had a nice chart illustrating both points, comparing median family income with real GDP per family (for those worried about the fine points, it was nominal GDP divided by the CPI, avoiding some technical issues):
You see the contrast: a doubling of family incomes in the post war generation compared with maybe 20 percent since, and family incomes growing in line with GDP before, lagging far behind since, with the difference basically being the rising share of the 1 percent.
This is real stuff, not some trivial envy-driven concern. But we must be very, very quiet about it, right?
Lane Kenworthy had a nice chart illustrating both points, comparing median family income with real GDP per family (for those worried about the fine points, it was nominal GDP divided by the CPI, avoiding some technical issues):
This is real stuff, not some trivial envy-driven concern. But we must be very, very quiet about it, right?
Tuesday, January 17, 2012
For The Defense
Paul Krugman has a recent piece on his blog which makes the case for the efficacy of fiscal policy, even in the age of globalization. He has an indisputable point, and, I suppose, a useful one. But on the whole, I feel compelled to point out that it should not be necessary to have to make such a data rich and graphic argument to carry this debate.
Think of it this way: Prior to the age of economic globalization, a nation's economy was akin to a sound, leak free bucket. Globalization can be thought of for purposes of this example as punching several holes in the bottom, such that a certain quantity of investment and productive effort with which we fill the bucket, now runs out from below. Nevertheless, the bucket still fills to some level and holds there as long as the input stream remains steady. If we increase the fill stream and are careful not to make more holes in the bottom, a somewhat larger amount will leak out because of higher head pressure from above, but this same head pressure results from a higher fill level as well.
Anyone who fails to understand the basic physics and math at work here, simply is not being very thoughtful or else adopting a defeatist attitude. We can do much better than accepting either of those two possibilities.
Here is the Krugman post:
Think of it this way: Prior to the age of economic globalization, a nation's economy was akin to a sound, leak free bucket. Globalization can be thought of for purposes of this example as punching several holes in the bottom, such that a certain quantity of investment and productive effort with which we fill the bucket, now runs out from below. Nevertheless, the bucket still fills to some level and holds there as long as the input stream remains steady. If we increase the fill stream and are careful not to make more holes in the bottom, a somewhat larger amount will leak out because of higher head pressure from above, but this same head pressure results from a higher fill level as well.
Anyone who fails to understand the basic physics and math at work here, simply is not being very thoughtful or else adopting a defeatist attitude. We can do much better than accepting either of those two possibilities.
Here is the Krugman post:
Not So Global
Barry Ritholtz sends us to a San Francisco Fed paper from last summer that makes a point on which many people seem confused: despite globalization and all that, the bulk of a consumer dollar spent in America falls on American-produced goods and services.
The reason this matters — or at least one reason it matters — is for discussion of austerity, stimulus, and all that. I often get comments along the lines of “Well, maybe stimulus worked back in the old days, but now it just means spending more on stuff from China”. In reality, that’s nowhere near true.
Why? For one thing, most consumer spending is on services, few of which are really tradable. For another, even if the thing you buy in WalMart says “Made in China”, the price includes a lot of US value-added in the form of transportation and retailing costs.
Here’s the paper’s estimates of the share of personal consumption expenditure (PCE) spent on imports in general and imports from China:
So we’re still a country where about 85 cents of your consumer dollar is spent at home, one way or another. And this means, among other things, that the rules of macroeconomics haven’t changed nearly as much as people imagine.
The reason this matters — or at least one reason it matters — is for discussion of austerity, stimulus, and all that. I often get comments along the lines of “Well, maybe stimulus worked back in the old days, but now it just means spending more on stuff from China”. In reality, that’s nowhere near true.
Why? For one thing, most consumer spending is on services, few of which are really tradable. For another, even if the thing you buy in WalMart says “Made in China”, the price includes a lot of US value-added in the form of transportation and retailing costs.
Here’s the paper’s estimates of the share of personal consumption expenditure (PCE) spent on imports in general and imports from China:
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)